FOOD IRRADIATION UPDATE
June 17, 2003
Food Irradiation Update is published by the Minnesota Beef Council

Quotable Quotes:

"It is now up to parents and local school boards to educate themselves about food irradiation. When they do they will likely want the process used to enhance the safety of ground beef served to their children." Dr. Elizabeth Whelan, President, American Council on Science & Health

 

“My son went from being perfectly healthy to dead in about 10 days. We felt as if an invisible truck had run over him." The killer was Escherichia coli O157:H7, a bacterium that can contaminate ground beef and other meat.  (Kevin Kowalcyk’s family believes that he was killed by a hamburger contaminated with E. coli.)  Barbara Kowalcyk of Mount Horeb, Wis.

 

Food Irradiation: Threat of Food-borne Illness Greater Than Any Risk from Irradiation 
Health Panel Urges Schools, Parents to Approve Irradiated Meat for School Lunches

National Cattlemen's Beef Association Position on Inclusion of Irradiated Beef Products in the School Lunch Program

Unsafe Meat Ended or Tragically Changed Their Lives

International Meeting for Radiation Processing to be Held in Chicago September 7-12

Food Irradiation Education Activities

 

Food Irradiation: Threat of Food-borne Illness Greater Than Any Risk from
Irradiation
(June 16, 2003); The Times and Democrat via FSNET http://www.thetandd.com/articles/2003/06/16/opinion/opinion.txt
U.S. Department of Agriculture Undersecretary for Food Safety Elsa Murano declared, according to this editorial, when her agency announced ratifying purchase by local school boards for school lunch programs of irradiated cheese, poultry and red meat, ground or trimmed that, "Protecting the public
from foodborne illness is a priority. Irradiation technology is another tool to enhance food safety."

The editorial says that critics have already spoken up since government is ignoring their beliefs, and that groups opposed to chemical agriculture, nuclear energy and processed foods, as well as federal oversight of local activities, conform to frequently followed and long-known special interest tactics nationwide, not just in Washington. They don't start their preaching with facts. Many of them deliberately reject fact for not supporting their beliefs. When they stumble onto fact that they can twist or use to give a belief credibility, they'll restate it to do so.

The editorial says we side with the Food and Drug Administration on approval. Evidence tends to show far more danger from food-borne illnesses than the irradiation aimed at preventing them.

For example, studies involving the Centers for Disease Control and others indicate: Treating raw meat and poultry with irradiation at the slaughter plant could eliminate bacteria such as E. coli O157:H7, Salmonella and Campylobacter. These organisms currently cause millions of infections and thousands of hospitalizations in the United States every year. Irradiating ready-to-eat meats, like hot dogs and deli meats, could eliminate the risk of Listeria from such foods. Irradiation could also eliminate parasites like Cyclospora and bacteria like Shigella and Salmonella from fresh produce.

The potential benefit is also great for those dry foods that might be stored for long times and transported over great distances, such as spices and grains. Irradiation of animal feeds could prevent the spread of Salmonella and other pathogens to livestock through feeds. When irradiation is used, disease-causing germs are reduced or eliminated, the food does not become radioactive and dangerous substances do not appear in the foods. The nutritional value and taste are essentially unaffected.

In a high-tech world, support for the practice seems sense. And in places of mass feeding such as schools, using irradiated food is particularly logical.

 

Health Panel Urges Schools, Parents to Approve Irradiated Meat for School Lunches
(
May 30, 2003) American Council on Science and Health; from a press release:
http://www.acsh.org/press/releases/lunches060203.html
New York, NY: Specifications for purchase of irradiated ground beef for use in school lunches, though the decision to order irradiated beef will be made by local school districts. The American Council on Science and Health (ACSH), a consortium of more than 350 physicians and scientists, urges local school boards and parents to familiarize themselves with the safety benefits of the irradiated ground beef that is now available for the National School Lunch Program.

Irradiation of red meat was approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) late in 1997, the USDA established rules for its use in 1999, and food processors have been slowly adopting the process. Recently, a number of large supermarkets, fast food outlets, and direct mail meat suppliers have begun offering their customers the choice of irradiated, and therefore
safer, beef.

The use of irradiation on foods served in the school lunch program is especially appropriate because young children are among the groups that are particularly susceptible to serious consequences from consuming E. coli-contaminated foods. Therefore, parents should be relieved to learn that this technology will now be available for their children's protection.

Opponents of irradiation have repeatedly tried to arouse public fears, both of the process itself and of irradiation facilities, but their claims are without merit. Irradiation does not significantly affect the nutritional value of the foods treated, nor does it make food radioactive. Additionally, more than 40 irradiation facilities currently operate safely in towns and cities across the United States. In these plants radiation is used to sterilize products ranging from baby-bottle nipples and cream containers to scalpels and surgical gloves. The safety record of the industry is excellent.

According to ACSH Director of Nutrition Dr. Ruth Kava, "Some groups urge consumers to avoid irradiated foods because of purely hypothetical concerns about the process. We think that consumers should embrace the process because of its proven ability to improve food safety."

Irradiation has been approved by both the World Health Organization and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. In the United States, the American Medical Association, the American Dietetic Association, and the Institute of Food Technologists, as well as ACSH, endorse the use of irradiation to supplement the other methods currently used to safeguard our food supply.

Dr. Elizabeth Whelan, ACSH president stated that, "It is now up to parents and local school boards to educate themselves about food irradiation. When they do they will likely want the process used to enhance the safety of ground beef served to their children."
For more science-based information about irradiation of foods, please see ACSH's recently updated booklet, Irradiated Foods, which can be downloaded from: http://www.acsh.org/publications/booklets/irradiated2003.html
 

National Cattlemen's Beef Association Position on inclusion of irradiated beef products in the school lunch program; Statement by Terry Stokes, Chief Executive Officer (May 29, 2003):
 
The National Cattlemen's Beef Association (NCBA) supports the use of irradiation technologies as one of many safety measures that further improves the safety of food products. 
 
On May 1, 2003, USDA's Agriculture Marketing Service (AMS) announced specifications that added new process and testing requirements throughout the manufacturing process for all ground beef items purchased
for the National School Lunch Program.  U.S. beef is among the safest in the world, and these enhanced specifications will ensure this safe product is being made even safer.  
 
The USDA's Food Safety Inspection Service (FSIS) inspects all meat products, including those that are irradiated.  Only FSIS federally-inspected establishments and state-inspected facilities that meet the same requirements specified in the federal regulations are allowed to irradiate meat.  Plants that use irradiation must meet sanitation and Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Point regulations. Additionally, FSIS conducts microbial testing to be sure plants are producing wholesome products.   Following the irradiation process, tests will be repeated by AMS to further verify the beef is safe. 
 
NCBA supports USDA's plan to let each school system decide whether to purchase and serve irradiated beef products.  In addition, NCBA joins USDA in promoting the importance of communication within the school system and community, and urging that notification procedures be put in place at the local level to better inform parents.
 
"Key points include:
* FDA concluded that irradiation is safe in reducing harmful bacteria and that it does not compromise the nutritional quality of treated products.  The United Nation's World Health Organization, Codex
Alimentarius Commission, American Medical Association and many other health and medical organizations have endorsed the process.

* During irradiation, foods are exposed briefly to an ionizing energy source, such as x-rays or electron beams, to kill bacteria that may otherwise cause foodborne illness. 

* Food irradiation is approved in more than 40 countries around the world and has long been approved and used for wheat, spices and fresh fruits and vegetables in the U.S.

* Irradiation complements, but does not replace proper food handling and cooking practices, and the numerous testing and safeguard measures already in place."
 
 

Unsafe Meat Ended or Tragically Changed Their Lives; (June 6, 2003) Philadelphia Inquirer: By Aparna Surendran
PHILADELPHIA: A picture of Kevin Kowalcyk taken in July 2001 shows a cheerful blond boy, not yet 3 years old, kneeling on a sandy beach. Less than a month later, he was dead, killed by bacteria that ravaged his internal organs.

"My son went from being perfectly healthy to dead in about 10 days," said his mother, Barbara Kowalcyk of Mount Horeb, Wis. "We felt as if an invisible truck had run over him." The killer was Escherichia coli O157:H7, a bacterium that can contaminate ground beef and other meat. Kevin's family believes that he was killed by a hamburger contaminated with E. coli.

Each year in the United States, food contamination causes 76 million illnesses, 325,000 hospitalizations and 5,000 deaths. The four most common bacteria found in meat are E. coli, Listeria monocytogenes, Salmonella and Campylobacter. According to estimated figures from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, E. coli accounts for 73,000 illnesses and 60 deaths in the United States each year. There are 2,500 illnesses and 500 deaths due to Listeria annually. Salmonella causes 1.4 million illnesses and more than 500 deaths, and Campylobacter causes 2.4 million illnesses and 124 deaths each year.

Often, the victims remain faceless, nameless casualties of a war that is largely ignored.

Kevin Kowalcyk is one of those victims. So is 5-year-old Julia Capriotti, who has cerebral palsy because her mother contracted L. monocytogenes when she was pregnant. So is Melanie Moul, whose baby died because she contracted Listeria during pregnancy. So is Raymond Drayton, who was killed by a strain of Listeria blamed in several other deaths. So is 7-year-old Katelyn Koesterer, who needs a new pancreas because of an E. coli infection.

These are their stories.
___
On Tuesday, July 31, 2001, when Kevin woke up with a fever and diarrhea, his mother thought it was a 24-hour bug. By Wednesday, the diarrhea contained blood, so Barbara Kowalcyk and her husband, Michael, rushed their son to a Madison, Wis., hospital, where doctors ordered a stool sample and sent Kevin home. On Thursday, he was admitted to the hospital, and doctors told the family that the stool sample had tested positive for E. coli.

On Friday, Kevin's kidneys started to fail. "He almost died that night," his mother remembers. "He went kind of lethargic. He was cold, but he was sweating." Kevin was transferred to the University of Wisconsin Children's Hospital. By Saturday morning, his heart was racing at more than 200 beats a minute, and his blood pressure was very high. He was put on dialysis and given blood and plasma transfusions. "We couldn't give him water," his mother says. "He kept asking for water. He asked to go to the beach and to the pool. He kept asking for a bath."

When she finally gave him a sponge bath, he grabbed the sponge and bit it to get the water, Kowalcyk said.
"His stomach was distended. His eyes were sunken. His face was drawn," Kowalcyk said.

Kevin was on dialysis off and on until Tuesday, when he took a turn for the worse. The E. coli's toxins had gotten into his bloodstream, causing sepsis, an infection. The doctors put him on a ventilator and continuous dialysis. His body swelled to almost three times its normal size, and he had to have tubes inserted into him to drain the fluid from his lungs.

On Saturday, Aug. 11, Kevin's overworked heart stopped beating. Doctors twice revived him. But before they could put him on a heart and lung machine, his heart stopped beating for the third, and last, time. Kevin died of gangrene to his small and large intestines. E. coli had eaten thousands of holes in his intestines and had clogged the arteries carrying blood to the intestines.

Kevin's grandmother, Patricia Buck, of Grove City, Pa., was in Wisconsin when he died. "It was the most horrific thing I had to live through," Buck said. "This is a horrible death for a 2-year-old."

"I (thought) about how much pain he must have had and how scared he must have been," his mother said recently. "I couldn't do anything about it."

When Kevin was in the intensive-care unit, Kowalcyk, her husband, and their daughter Megan, then 5, all were tested by the Dane County Division of Public Health. But it wasn't until Buck called the department on Sept. 10, almost a month after Kevin died, that they got the test results: Both Michael and Megan Kowalcyk had tested positive for E. coli.

To this day, Kowalcyk does not know for sure how her family got sick. A week before Kevin went to the hospital, the family had hamburger twice, she said. They had gone to a county fair, where only Kevin, Megan and Michael ate hamburgers; the second time was a family meal at home.

Kevin's death has transformed his parents into outspoken advocates for tougher food-safety laws. The U.S. Department of Agriculture lacks the authority to close plants that exceed limits for bacterial contamination, issue mandatory recalls or impose civil fines. A bill introduced last year by Sen. Tom Harkin (D.-Iowa) and set to be reintroduced Thursday would allow the USDA to set limits for contamination by pathogens such as E. coli. This proposed legislation has become known as Kevin's Law.

"A lot of times the consumer is blamed. (They say) we don't use hygiene or cook (meat) properly," Kowalcyk said. "We did everything we were supposed to. We used separate plates and utensils. I clean sinks and the counter when I prepare meat. I would wash hot dogs before I cook them! A lot of our friends were floored because they know how meticulous I am."

Megan is now 7, and the Kowalcyks have an 8-month-old, Lara. The family still goes to counseling to deal with the grief of Kevin's death, Kowalcyk said. "Kevin was very gentle," Kowalcyk said. "He would cry easily if someone else was crying. He was very sweet, and oh, I loved him," Kowalcyk said. "I was madly in love with Kevin. He was a wonderful little boy."
___
Dan Capriotti, 42, hoisted his little brown-haired girl up over his shoulder and back down. Up, down, up, down, as Julia threw her head back and squealed. When he finally put her down, he held on firmly so that she did not fall.

Julia, 5, who stands about 3 feet tall and weighs 25 pounds, has cerebral palsy. She can't walk or stand on her own. She has difficulty using her right hand and needs speech, physical and occupational therapy.

Julia's problems began before she was born. Her mother, Lynn Nowak, was 26 [ weeks pregnant when she began experiencing flu-like symptoms on Sept. 2, 1997. She had body aches, chills, a 102-degree fever and a terrible headache. By midnight, she could no longer feel her baby move inside her.

The next day, an ultrasound revealed that the baby had a high heartbeat but was not moving. Her doctor said the baby most likely had an infection, and they would have to deliver immediately.

Doctors took out Julia by Caesarean section early the following morning. She weighed 2 pounds, 2 ounces. She hovered near death; a priest was called to give the baby last rites.

Julia survived, but her esophagus was torn; she had bleeding in her brain, which obstructed the flow of cerebrospinal fluid; and she had heart problems. All of this, the doctors said, was due to something the Capriotti family had never heard of _ Listeria monocytogenes, a food-borne pathogen associated particularly with precooked meats. Meat plants usually use steam or high pressure to kill the bacterium in packaged unsliced deli meats, said Dan Murphy, vice president of public affairs at the American Meat Institute. For hot dogs and sliced deli meats, there is regulation pending to permit irradiation to kill Listeria, he said. But because the threat of L. monocytogenes is in the plant environment, it is more important to clean equipment and drains, Murphy said. A four-step process involves removing visible debris, cleaning with detergent, rinsing with hot water and spraying a sanitizer.

Julia came home for good on New Year's Day 1998, but she could not sit up by herself. When Julia was about a year old, her neurologist said she had cerebral palsy. "I was scared; I felt guilty," Nowak said. "I was just so glad to have this little girl, (but) I ate whatever caused this."

To this day, Nowak does not know how L. monocytogenes got into her system and then into Julia's. The summer she was pregnant, she was careful to eat well-done hamburgers, because of the threat of E. coli contamination. But she had never heard of L. monocytogenes, which can infect uncooked meat and vegetables and is also found in soft cheeses and processed foods such as ready-to-eat cold cuts. Nowak says now that she frequently ate cold cuts without special precautions.

Nowak and her husband have since become vocal critics of the food-safety system. "There are economic forces at work," said Capriotti, Julia's father.

Recently, there was a ground-beef recall that included meat Capriotti had purchased at his local A&P. When he went back to return the meat, the store manager thanked him and said he had not heard about the recall, Capriotti said.

"Where is the power in the recall?" Capriotti said. "Where is the efficacy? How can we as consumers protect ourselves in a system like that? "Because someone didn't do his or her job right, my daughter has to pay a price for the rest of her life."
___

Melanie Moul's first pregnancy was normal until the 24th week. At the end of December 1998, she woke up with a fever of 103. The fever rose to 105, and she went to the hospital. After that, a lot of what happened is a blank for Moul.

"I was so numb," she says now. She drifted asleep, and when she woke up, she was having the baby, recalls Moul, 37, of Sewickley, Pa., near Pittsburgh. "I delivered Hope on Dec. 29," Moul said. "She lived for 10 minutes." An autopsy showed that L. monocytogenes had infected the baby.

"They found the placenta polluted with Listeria," Moul said. Moul said she ate hot dogs, which can carry L. monocytogenes, with her two stepdaughters in October 1998. During Thanksgiving, she developed flu-like symptoms.

"I had a fever," she said. "I was so tired and exhausted. But that's just pregnancy, you think." Moul did not go to the doctor then, because her symptoms cleared up. She did not think about it until almost a month later, when she landed in the hospital.

The Mouls later sued Sara Lee Corp., the maker of Ballpark hot dogs, on behalf of Hope; they reached a settlement in 2000. A Sara Lee representative said the company did not "comment on any litigation during or after. We have a good-faith agreement with parties involved that we will not comment."

"I just had to fight, because it was the best thing that could get me out of depression," Moul said. "They (Sara Lee) needed to be held responsible." Meat-processing companies too often think about the financial aspects of testing, Moul said.

"I wish that these companies could let go of the thought of money," she said. "They expended some lives. That part angers me."

Moul has since had three children: Emma, 3, and 1-year-old twins Abigail and Tabitha. But she often thinks of Hope.

"It was a horrible night and a horrible experience," she said. Hope died "over a hot dog. It is sad."
___
When Renee Drayton rushed to a Philadelphia hospital from her Silver Spring, Md., home in August, she had never heard of Listeria.

Her father, Raymond, 75, had been taken to the hospital after her mother, Lawese, found him doubled over in his bed on Aug. 28. In late August, Raymond Drayton had felt sick, but dismissed his symptoms as those of Crohn's disease, an inflammatory disease of the gastrointestinal tract from which he suffered.

The doctors ran tests on her father and said he had listeriosis. They gave him antibiotics, Renee Drayton said, but he died Sept. 1. Health investigators found that Raymond Drayton had eaten deli meat contaminated with a strain of L. monocytogenes. The brand of meat has not been identified, the family said.

The strain of bacteria that killed Drayton was the same "outbreak" strain blamed for 53 illnesses and eight deaths in the Northeast last year.

Last month, Lawese Drayton filed a wrongful-death lawsuit against Montgomery County, Pa., meat-processing plant Wampler Foods Inc. and J.L. Foods Co. Inc. of Camden, N.J.

In October, Wampler recalled 27.4 million pounds of poultry. According to the CDC, a strain of Listeria "indistinguishable" from the outbreak strain was found in drainage areas in the plant. In November, J.L. Foods recalled 4.2 million pounds of poultry. The CDC said a strain of Listeria "indistinguishable" from the outbreak strain was found on a sample of turkey breast.

J.L. Foods could not be reached for comment, and a written statement by Pilgrim's Pride said the company would not comment on pending litigation.

Raymond Drayton "purchased ready-to-eat poultry meat a week or so prior to his death," said Jonathan Dailey, one of Drayton's lawyers. "He was diagnosed with Listeria, and it was his cause of death. It was the outbreak strain that killed (him)."

The USDA needs to get tougher with meat processors, Renee Drayton said. Her father's death could have been prevented, she said. Listeria, she said, is not an airborne disease like severe acute respiratory syndrome, or SARS.

It is "something we have control over to some degree," she said.
___
Like many of her classmates, Katelyn Koesterer, 7, got a stomach virus in January. But unlike her classmates, she became so weak that doctors advised her parents to home-school her for the rest of the winter until she got stronger. She went back to school only six weeks ago. Her immune system is too weak to risk further illness.

It wasn't always this way for Katelyn, whose life changed dramatically last May. It was barbecue season, and the Koesterer family, of Orangeburg, N.Y., had been eating hamburgers frequently. Katelyn, then 6, developed bloody diarrhea on May 23; her parents took her to Nyack Hospital on May 25, but the doctors diagnosed it as a virus. By May 27, she was taken to Westchester Medical Center, and by May 29, doctors told Katelyn's mother, Ann, that her child had E. coli in her system.

Over the next several days, Katelyn's kidneys failed. She continued to have bloody diarrhea and was vomiting, and she also developed pancreatitis, an inflammation of the pancreas. She had one major seizure; her left vocal cord was left paralyzed. She required blood and plasma transfusions.

She was released from the hospital June 25 but was back in the emergency room four days later. A CT scan showed that she had a pseudocyst, a collection of tissue, fluid, enzymes and blood, on her pancreas, her mother said.

Surgery was prescribed, but doctors at Columbia-Presbyterian Medical Center in New York disagreed, saying the girl's pancreas was "mush" and surgery could not be done. Now, Katelyn is expected to need a pancreas transplant and may also need a kidney transplant, her mother said.

Today, Katelyn is an insulin-dependent diabetic. She has to take pancreatic enzymes to digest her food, along with medication to lower her blood sugar.

She has gotten her voice back, though it does not sound the same as it did before the E. coli infection, her mother said.

Dennis and Ann Koesterer have sued BJ's Wholesale Club Inc., where they bought the hamburger meat that Katelyn ate. They are seeking $30 million. The ground beef they bought at BJ's West Nyack store tested positive for E. coli. So did the ground beef purchased by another customer at BJ's about the same time. On July 16, more than two months after Dennis Koesterer bought hamburger there, BJ's contacted 131 people who had bought meat at the same time as the Koesterers and asked them to return the meat for a refund.

The company has declined to pay for Katelyn's medical bills, Koesterer said. BJ's spokeswoman Julie Somers said the company would not comment on pending litigation.

"People rely on the USDA label without realizing what the USDA function is," Ann Koesterer said. "We are relying too much on companies to self-audit or self-inspect without any oversight.

"We have so many oversight boards. But we don't have one over our food?"

"You strap your child to a car seat and make sure it is safe," she said. "Yet I put a hamburger onto her plate and it nearly killed her."
___
(c) 2003, The Philadelphia Inquirer.

 

International Meeting for Radiation Processing to be Held in Chicago September 7-12: The International Meeting for Radiation Processing (IMRP 2003) will be held September 7-12 at the Fairmont Hotel in Chicago, Illinois, the optimum location for attracting those segments of food and other industries interested in advancing and expanding the industrial applications of ionizing radiation.

IMRP 2003 is the most important meeting for the exchange of information on the science and technology of radiation processing. These dual conference meetings are organized to gather the world's experts in the radiation field, and to explore the industrial applications of E-beams, X-rays, and gamma rays. It is also an opportunity to present new products, new technologies, new processes, new standards, and new applications.

To encourage participation by food industry representatives, IMRP 2003 has increased the dedicated segments of IMRP that are devoted to food irradiation.  Overall food session topics will include Marketing, Food Irradiation Overview,  Market Segments,  Education, and Market Trends and Forecasts.

 

Food Irradiation Education Activities:
The Minnesota Beef Council, in cooperation with SureBeam Corporation will be assisting with, conducting or participating in the following irradiation education activities:

St. Peter, MN; June 19, 2003: National Conference of Watershed Heroes Conference

Ft. Pierre, SD; June 20-22, 2003: American National CattleWomen Region VII Workshop
St. Paul, MN; June 24, 2003: Country of Origin Information Session (Irradiated Burgers Served)

Dallas, TX; June 25, 2003: Texas Beef Council Food Irradiation Workshop

New Ulm, MN; June 27, 2003: Hub Club Farm/City Celebration

St. Paul, MN; July 2, 2003; North American MENSA Convention

St. Paul, MN; July 9, 2003: Minnesota Food & Nutrition Network Meeting

Green Bay, WI; July 13-15, 2003: National Association of County Agricultural Agents
Brainerd, MN; July 18-19, 2003: Brainerd Barbecue Fest

Beckley, WV; July 24, 2003: 57th Annual Environmental Health Seminar

River Falls, WI; August 9, 2003: St. Croix County Farm City Day

St. Paul, MN; August 21-September 1, 2003: Minnesota State Fair

Chicago, IL; September 7-12, 2003:  International Meeting for Radiation Processing (IMRP 2003)

Jasper, IN; Sept. 23, 2003: Indiana Environmental Health Association Conference

Tennessee; October 3, 2003: Tennessee Cattlemen Annual Meeting

 

Food Irradiation Update is being sent as an update on food irradiation by the Minnesota Beef Council.  If for any reason you do not want to receive these updates please hit Reply and ask us to delete you from the list of recipients.

Ronald F. Eustice
Executive Director
Minnesota Beef Council
2950 Metro Drive # 102
Bloomington, MN 55425
USA
Phone: 952/854-6980
Fax: 952/854-6906
E-mail:
ron@mnbeef.org
Website: www.mnbeef.org