Cargill and Tyson
found in 'contempt' of Canadian Parliament;
by Daniel Yovich on 5/7/04 for Meatingplace.com:
Cargill Foods and Tyson Foods have been found in contempt of a Canadian
Parliament panel investigating whether some of that country's largest processors
unfairly benefited from financial aid doled out by the government in the wake of
Canada's announcement last May it had discovered an Alberta cow infected with
bovine spongiform encephalopathy.
The panel is questioning why producers have been getting rock-bottom prices for
their cattle since last year's BSE discovery, while consumers aren't paying
substantially less for their beef at the grocery store. Consumer groups have
blamed the country's larger processors, and the panel has subpoenaed financial
records from Canada's five largest packers.
Cargill and Tyson have not forwarded their financial records to the committee,
twice missing extended deadlines set by the panel.
"Cargill and Tyson know perfectly well they wouldn't get away with this for
five minutes in the United States, if they treated their Congress with the
contempt that they've treated us," committee member and Liberal MP David
Kilgour told the Canadian Press. "We've stood up and I think it's
a strong victory, above all for the cow-calf producers, 34,000 of them across
our province."
Canadian television showed broadcasts Thursday night of committee members saying
they have been advised by House of Commons lawyers that they can jail company
officials for failing to comply with the subpoenas.
Cargill spokesman Robert Meijer said the company doesn't believe the committee
could keep the records confidential. Cargill lawyers are looking at the contempt
order to determine the company's next move.
"We continue to believe that these requests are unreasonable," Meijer
said from Winnipeg. "As a privately held firm, we're entitled to have our
privacy interests respected and protected. We work very hard to keep our records
safe from our competitors.